In all fields of entertainment, which surpasses the entire metal category, there are several acts made to shock their audience. Whether it’s paying a visit to New York City’s Sleep No More, watching a disturbing film, participating in an escape room, attending a circus, or watching a wrestling match; these experiences are made to have a thrilling or frightening experience. With that said, the same can be applied to music. However, how far is too far?
Over the last few years alone, Antifa groups have found a way to get shows cancelled, especially black metal shows. Earlier this year, we were disappointed to hear about Taake’s U.S. tour being cancelled. Despite the group’s explanation and apologies over the last 11 years, Antifa reminded all on the band’s shocking performance back in 2007 when band leader, Hoest performed live with a swastika painted on his chest in Germany. Placing shock value to entertain can get tricky and messy as it can turn into something offensive and unforgivable. However, music has an extensive history with courting controversy for shock value purposes as well as reminding all that history should not repeat itself including hip-hop artists that have raised a Confederate flag to nearly the entire punk scene from the 70s and 80s, and many more. Due to the extensive history in entertainment, there is a blurred line between what’s shockingly entertaining and horribly shocking.
Prior to Taake’s entire U.S tour being cancelled, Talib Kweli cancelled his Kansas City gig due to the Norwegian black metal outfit had booked the same venue. While Taake were aiming to perform music across the country not to inflict hate and physical violence, an Antifa group publicly threatened the band and their fans. We had spoken to Hoest about these claims as the group issued a statement as well on Facebook clarifying they are not, were not, and never will be a Nazi band.
Fast forward to today (19th), Kweli has returned to cancel a show at the Rockerfeller Music Hall in Oslo, Norway due to the same reasons from February: Taake are booked to perform at the same venue on April 19th at the Inferno Metal Festival.
Kweli explained via a series of Tweets/re-Tweets about the situation:
You nazi AF RT @henriklunde: @AndreasNordal @TalibKweli @ramiallolah Good point. The Swastika have been used to shock loads of times. Doesn’t make the users nazi just by doing thst. Slightly stupid maybe, but not nazi.
— Talib Kweli Greene (@TalibKweli) November 19, 2018
I’ve been really trippin off these “fans” not respecting or supporting him. You can’t be a fan. Him canceling for this reason are exactly his beliefs. Why would you want him to? They’re not even Fairweather. They’re fake. I for one am excited he’s not
— AYR AMERYCA 👻 (@_AYR_7) November 19, 2018
it’s funny how clowns are trying to lash at you for doing the right thing, as usual. we keep an eye on them and we’re organising to take measures against the venue and all the nazis that are surfacing with this.
— javi (cucu de izqui) (@javitrino) November 19, 2018
I love making Nazis famous. This way we know who they are. Yup. RT @drammen86: @iamjohnk @TalibKweli @BLUE62007611 @beining I’m so glad we actually have education in Norway. You guys make no sense. Great work on making that shit band Taake famous btw. Assholes
— Talib Kweli Greene (@TalibKweli) November 19, 2018
Who knew there were so many Nazi apologists in Oslo? No wonder the venue choose the Nazi band over me. Then know who butters their bread…. @lasylays @rockefelleroslo https://t.co/s18a2EpOiI
— Talib Kweli Greene (@TalibKweli) November 19, 2018
Yea you sound like a real stand up guy. @andreasnordal https://t.co/7w4AkOQrRr
— Talib Kweli Greene (@TalibKweli) November 19, 2018
Why does Rockefeller work w a festival that books Nazis? RT @Frk_Mona: @mohamabd86 @henriklunde @TalibKweli @ramiallolah @rockefelleroslo They didn’t. They have a deal with Inferno, a festival. It’s Inferno that has booked Taake. So it’s not Rockefeller that booked Taake.
— Talib Kweli Greene (@TalibKweli) November 19, 2018
— Talib Kweli Greene (@TalibKweli) November 19, 2018
I can do whatever I want you nazi loving bitch. And that includes canceling shows at venues that invite Nazis in. RT @henriklunde: @TalibKweli @AndreasNordal @ramiallolah All you can do is shout? Do you boycott all venues that ever staged a Sex Pistols show also? or….?
— Talib Kweli Greene (@TalibKweli) November 19, 2018
Nobody asked you go back to being irrelevant and doing nothing worthwhile with your life. @ghostwritercas https://t.co/iSIvFyZmCd
— Talib Kweli Greene (@TalibKweli) November 19, 2018
Y’all should go protest Rockefeller tonight and let them know how upset you are that anti fascist artists like me are standing up to their decision to book Nazis. But you won’t. Cuz you a fraud. @ghostwritercas https://t.co/1q6ZAHPzwb
— Talib Kweli Greene (@TalibKweli) November 19, 2018
I canceled the moment I found out they were booked. You’re an asshole. Mind your business you whiny baby. @beining https://t.co/xvnIIbu8Xv
— Talib Kweli Greene (@TalibKweli) November 19, 2018
So a white nationalist band from Norway decided it would be a great idea to wave a swastika at a show in Germany, but they not Nazis? 😒 RT @jpsalvesen: @tracylacy84 @TalibKweli @ramiallolah I pretty much agree with you. But know this: They used it once. In Germany.
— Talib Kweli Greene (@TalibKweli) November 19, 2018
My show at @rockerfelleroslo in Norway is canceled tonight. It was brought to my attention they support Nazi bands. They refused to have a conversation about it so I canceled. Here is a… https://t.co/Ahc27s4i8S
— Talib Kweli Greene (@TalibKweli) November 19, 2018
Kick rocks Nazi lover. Bye. RT @tellingsen: @3244Chill @ChiragKarpe @TalibKweli @ramiallolah We don’t. Not sure I’m a fan anymore, either. If that makes me a «fake fan», I’ll live with that.
— Talib Kweli Greene (@TalibKweli) November 19, 2018
I guess you support venues that invite Nazis in. Fake fan. Fuck you. RT @Komanson: @ChiragKarpe @TalibKweli @ramiallolah @TalibKweli you are completly missing the ball om this one. I guess Reflection Eternal means nothing after all…
— Talib Kweli Greene (@TalibKweli) November 19, 2018
If your desire to be personally entertained by me is stronger than your desire to support me in calling out and not supporting a venue that invites Nazis in, you’re a selfish Nazi defending piece of shit and I don’t want you as my fan. Clear? @ghostwritercas https://t.co/ExZkdqEPWC
— Talib Kweli Greene (@TalibKweli) November 19, 2018
Meanwhile, Pitchfork reached out to Hoest as he responded with the following statement:
“He seriously thinks we’re Nazis? I have done nothing but deny this for the past eleven years, but this is what happens when Antifa run one of their slanderous campaign—there is always some jerk who takes them seriously. Personally I think it was an appalling thing to do both to his fans, and the venue, with which we have had good relations for the past 15 years.
I was a bit surprised to find he had booked this particular European show. I didn’t want to sink to his level by making anyone aware of it and spoiling it for him and his fans, even though that is something he himself seems to take great pride and pleasure in doing to other bands. Not sure if he is playing in any other venues in Europe where Taake also plays regularly.
At the end of the day I imagine this will now give venues world-wide pause for thought before actually booking and promoting him in case he is likely to agree to do a show and then pull out at the last minute because of other bands who have played there in the past, or who are booked to play in the future.”
[via ThePrp]