Nine Inch Nails have been surprising their fans during their current North American trek as they’ve performed “The Perfect Drug” for the first time ever live as well as opening up more than one of their sets with the entire 1992 EP, Broken. During the group’s first-scheduled Chicago date on Thursday (25th) at the Aragon Ballroom, the band stunned their fans once again by performing “Starfuckers, Inc.” for the first time since 2008.

Watch the fan-filmed clip below: