We’re Metal Insider, not E!, but when one of the most successful comedic actresses out there comes fresh off of co-hosting the Golden Globes to show up at an after-party with an Iron Maiden shirt  on, you’re damn right we’re going to report about it! Ketel One tweeted out a photo of Poehler at her own after-party with a well-earned martini sporting a well-worn Maiden shirt from Somewhere In Time.

Whether Poehler’s a Maiden fan from back in the day (she would have been 15 when Maiden’s fifth album came out) or a stylist picked the shirt out for her is up for debate, but she just earned a few more cool points in our book regardless (not to mention, she did a great Bill Cosby impersonation, too!).